Want to know what the best mulch is for your vegetable garden? What we know

Mulch is a versatile and useful tool for any gardener. It helps suppress weeds, keeps the soil insulated, improves water retention, helps reduce fungal infections in plants’ leaves, and it can even look nice. There are plenty of different types of mulch, though, so how do you know which type is best for your vegetable garden? If you’re overwhelmed by all the mulch types out there, or if you’re just curious about your options, then you’re in the right place! We’ll walk you through all the factors that can impact your choice, and even give you an overview of the different types of mulch.

What to look for in mulch

There are a few different things to look for in mulch, depending on your needs. One thing to consider is whether or not the mulch is organic. If you’re an organic gardener and want your mulch to be organic as well, then you’ll need to pay close attention to labels. Organic can mean both made with plant matter and made without the use of artificial chemicals. Many mulches that are labeled as organic actually use the first definition, since there are both organic and inorganic types of mulch. Read the packaging carefully to determine if your mulch is made organically. A great way to avoid this confusion is to make your mulch.

Recommended Videos

Pet safety is another thing to look for if you have a dog that likes to chew on things. Mulches that are treated with harsh chemicals are an obvious thing to look out for, but materials also matter. Look for finely shredded mulches, so they’re easier to digest, and double-check that materials are non-toxic. Alternatively, use gravel mulch, which dogs are much less likely to bite.

Nadzeya Pakhomava/Shutterstock

What to avoid in mulch

We’ve already mentioned avoiding mulches that have been treated with harsh chemicals, but it’s worth repeating. If you have outdoor pets who might chew on your mulch or who might roll in it and pick up chemicals on their fur, then this is especially important. Mulch that has been sprayed with chemicals is typically labeled as “treated,” such as treated wood mulch.

Just like the pesticides, you might spray on your plants, chemicals in your mulch have a chance of washing into the dirt or nearby water when it rains. This doesn’t necessarily mean you should never use mulch that has been sprayed or treated, but it does mean that you should be aware of what you’re putting into your garden.

You should also avoid mulch that is old or contains insects. This is more likely to be a problem if you are making mulch at home or reusing inorganic mulch. Old mulch may be partially broken down, which may not be an issue for gravel or organic mulches. However, it is potentially harmful if the mulch is plastic or fabric since pieces or fibers could escape into your soil. Insects infesting mulch that’s transferred to your garden will then infest your garden. While some insects are beneficial, many are not.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

What are the different types of mulch?

Organic mulch: Wood chip, grass, straw, and leaf

Organic mulch is mulch made from plant matter. It can be made of almost anything, but the most common forms are wood chips, grass clippings, straw or pine straw, and leaf mulch. Compost can also be used as mulch and falls into this category.

Organic mulch will break down over time, which assists with the clean-up process, as you can simply mix them into the soil once you’re done with them.  This means they also add nutrients to the soil. Grass and straw break down the fastest, followed by leaves and finally wood chips. Organic mulch works well as an insulator, especially straw. It’s also the easiest mulch to make at home. Straw or leaf mulch is often the best choices for vegetable gardens, as they break down at a medium pace, contain plenty of nutrients, and are good insulators.

Inorganic mulch: Gravel, fabric, rubber, and plastic

Inorganic mulch is not made from plant matter, but instead from non-living materials like rocks, fabric, rubber, and plastic. Fabric may stand out to you since some fabrics are made from plants. However, it’s still considered inorganic as it takes much longer to break down.

Since they don’t break down, inorganic mulches don’t offer any nutritional benefits to the soil. Additionally, they’re more difficult to make at home and need to be manually removed once you’re done using them. However, they do have the benefit of being reusable if stored properly. Make sure they’re clean and free of insects, then store them in a dry place, preferably in a container. Before reusing it, visually inspect it for signs of damage or pests.

No matter what type of mulch you choose, this guide will help you make sure you’ve got the right one for you. Mulch has plenty of benefits even before you add on the benefits that each type brings to the table. Whether your plants need insulation from the cold, consistently moist soil, or help to compete against weeds, mulch is a great solution.

Editors' Recommendations

Cayla Leonard is a writer from North Carolina who is passionate about plants.  She enjoys reading and writing fiction and…
Hardening off your seedlings as you bring them outside is crucial – here’s how to do it
Tips to help you successfully transplant your seedlings

Even gloomy winter days can't stop enthusiastic gardeners. Unsurprisingly, many avid gardeners start their plants indoors when cold temperatures and unpredictable precipitation bar them from directly sowing their seeds outside. Still, the last frost date eventually comes around, and that's when it's time to bring those baby seedlings outside. Transporting seedlings outside is a simple process, but it still requires savvy coordination to prevent unwanted transplant shock. To help you keep your plants happy and healthy as they situate outside, we'll show you how to harden off seedlings.

What does hardening off seedlings mean?

Read more
Here’s what you should know about the updated USDA Hardiness Zone Map
These facts may help you as you begin your spring gardening

There’s major news in the gardening community: The USDA Hardiness Zone Map has been updated. If you’re a seasoned gardener, there’s a good chance that you’re familiar with this climate zone map, as it generally gives growers a good idea of which plants work in their area. But what does it mean for your spring garden if the map has been redrawn? Here’s what you need to know about the map, the change, and how it all impacts what you can grow in your yard. 
What is the USDA Hardiness Zone Map?

With the USDA Hardiness Zone Map, the U.S. Department of Agriculture splits the United States into 13 regions, using lowest average temperature ranges to designate specific planting zones. It’s simple to understand: Zone 1 is the coldest, whereas zone 13 is the warmest. Each zone is separated by 10-degree increments, but some gardeners like to get more granular and divide each zone into 5-degree increments (think zone 9A vs. zone 9b). 

Read more
What is a chaos garden, and why should you start one this spring?
Is this approach to gardening for you?

One of TikTok's latest gardening trends, chaos gardening is exactly what it sounds like: It's a low-maintenance approach to gardening that requires little planning and upkeep. With chaos gardening, you'll be using leftover seeds, picking out easy-going native plants, and being OK with some plants simply not working out. Think of it as survival of the fittest — whatever sticks will stick. There's no need to excessively plan out your spacing and consistently prune. Still, there's a method to the madness, since you want to keep your garden resilient against pests and diseases. If you're starting your very own chaos garden, here's what you need to know.

What you need to know about chaos gardening

Read more