Skip to main content

The benefits of composting and why it’s worth the effort

People have been composting in one way or another for over a thousand years. The word compost actually has its origins in the Latin word “compostia,” meaning “something put together.” It’s common knowledge at this point that composting involves putting vegetable scraps and dirt into a box, possibly with worms, but if that’s all you know about it, here are some things to keep in mind should you decide to incorporate composting to your garden.

The pros and cons of composting

The positives for composting are that it is good for the environment, good for your garden, a useful skill to have, and a good way to teach children about decomposition and the nitrogen cycle or to learn about it yourself. Going out to the bin or pile can be a way to teach the value of hard work and the food chain, and it can also help build physical strength as you turn the compost with a shovel or rake. It increases the health of your plants and reduces food waste.

On the other hand, composting does take time, energy, and space. Composting can be challenging if you don’t produce a lot of food scraps, or if you aren’t able to spend time maintaining your bin or pile. Compost typically only smells like earth, but sometimes it smells pretty bad. If your compost starts smelling, not only does it take some time and effort to fix, but the smells can also linger. If your compost is near your house, that can become a problem. Plus, compost smells can also attract animals, especially if you add meat to your compost.

Shovel placed on top of a compost pile

Should you have a compost bin?

Here are a few things to consider when deciding if you should start composting. How much compostable food scraps do you regularly produce? Compost needs organic matter, like vegetable or fruit peels, vegetable greens and tops, leftover vegetable bits, meat, grass clippings, and manure. Composting is wonderful, but if you don’t have anything to compost with, it’s just a box of dirt. You can scale your bin size to match the amount of food scraps you have, but you do want to make sure that you have enough material for a viable pile.

Think about how much time and energy you have to devote to a compost bin or pile. Starting the compost bin can require a lot of energy, depending on the size and location of your bin. If you’re busy, stressed, or ill, you can still compost, but take your needs into consideration. Start with a smaller bin, maybe an empty trash can rather than a large wooden construction, and make sure your bin is easily accessible. Smaller bins that are easily accessible are also the solution to space constraints. If you live in a small or shared space, or in a place where there is limited access to the outdoors, start with a small compost bin.

The most important question to ask yourself, though, is do you want to compost? If you do, then there is no reason why you shouldn’t have a bin. You can make a compost bin that fits with your life and needs. Even if it doesn’t look like the stereotypical platonic ideal of a compost bin, that doesn’t mean it won’t work. If you need a smaller bin, or a bin that’s made of unconventional materials, or a bin that opens sideways, then make your bin like that. On the flip side, if you don’t want to compost, don’t force yourself to do it. If the idea of composting makes you frustrated or makes you want to quit gardening, then don’t do it. There are other ways you can nourish your plants and other ways to reduce food waste.

Compost in brown bag on a floor
UliAb / Shutterstock

Is composting good for the environment?

Composting is good for the environment on multiple levels. It’s good for your garden specifically, as it gives your plants a boost. It also reduces the amount of food waste you have and recycles nutrients back into the soil. Composting is a natural part of the nitrogen cycle, which we have harnessed for our own purposes. The reduction of food waste is actually one of the biggest benefits to the environment. Composting your food scraps instead of throwing them away decreases the amount of garbage you’re producing, which ultimately means you’re producing less greenhouse gases such as methane.

Composting can be as versatile as you want it to be. It’s good for the environment and your garden, and it can be good for you, too. Don’t stress over your soil, just start small!

Cayla Leonard
Cayla Leonard is a writer from North Carolina who is passionate about plants.  She enjoys reading and writing fiction and…
Can you get rid of that terrible compost stench?
How to fix unpleasant compost smells
A metal bucket labeled compost, laying on its side against a blue background. Food scraps spill out of it.

Composting is one of the easiest ways to make your own fertilizer for your garden. Sometimes, though, decomposition doesn’t smell very nice. While the earthy smell of healthy compost doesn't appeal to everyone, it shouldn't smell terrible. If your compost smells deeply unpleasant then it might be a sign that something is wrong with it. Luckily, these issues are easy to identify and fix! This simple guide will walk you through what to do when your compost smells bad.

Why does my compost smell bad?
Compost should smell mostly like dirt, or, at its worst, like a forest in fall. If your compost smells bad, there are a few different things that could be wrong with it. Here's a rundown on what might be going on in your compost.
Moisture
The easiest problem to identify is too much moisture in your compost. If you had a lot of wet weather just before your compost started smelling, this is likely the issue. You can also identify this by sight and texture. Compost should be moist but not soggy.
Over-compacted compost
Another problem you can identify by sight and texture is over-compacted compost. If your compost is too compacted or too moist, it means your compost isn’t getting enough air, which is bad for your compost, but it also means that the smell has nowhere to go.
Compost that's been too layered
Similar to becoming compacted, your compost might be too layered. The easiest way to detect this issue is by thinking about how you add matter to your compost bin. If you add a layer of leaves, vegetables, grass clippings, etc., then add a layer of soil on top of that and let it sit; this creates layers in your compost. Layers trap most of the decomposition in one place. This limits air flow and over time can lead to your bin becoming compacted, as well.
The contents of the compost
If your compost isn’t wet, compacted, or layered, the issue is likely in what you’re adding to your compost. When the issue is with what’s in the bin, you can typically determine the problem by smell. If your compost smells like ammonia, the problem is likely that your compost has too much green material. That means your bin has more vegetable scraps, grass clippings, and wet leaves than it does soil, straw, and dry leaves. Your compost may also smell if you’ve recently added manure or meat to it.

Read more
Can you compost meat? What you need to know
What to do with your meat scraps
A person composting greens

Compost is an easy way to reduce your food waste and add nutrients to your garden soil, so it's no wonder that it's popular with home gardeners. Most types of plant matter can be composted, including things like paper and cardboard. Something you may be wondering, whether a new or seasoned composter, is, "Can you compost meat?" Well, the answer is complicated.

Whether you can compost meat scraps will depend on how much time you can dedicate to your compost pile, how experienced you are, and how much space you have. To learn all about how to compost meat safely, why you might not want to, and what to do with your meat scraps instead, keep reading this simple guide.

Read more
Why mulching might be the best option for your old Christmas tree
Turn your Christmas tree into eco-friendly mulch
Person carrying old Christmas tree

The gifts have been exchanged, the parties have ended, and you're ushering your relatives out the door so you can enjoy the last of the holiday season in peace. There's just one lingering loose end to tie up: What in the world are you going to do with that huge, old Christmas tree?

If you have an artificial tree that’s still in good shape, the answer is simple — just pack it back into the box and put it into the attic or garage for another year. What about a natural tree, though? With environmental sustainability an ever-growing consideration for consumers, it’s no longer as simple as tossing the tree into the next available garbage truck.

Read more