Skip to main content

5 silly tree myths we’re debunking this Arbor Day

Trees are so beneficial and widely revered that they even have a whole holiday devoted to them: Arbor Day. This day is all about the wonders of nature, and it’s even a tradition to plant a tree to celebrate it. But even though trees have a stellar reputation, there’s plenty of misinformation about these towering, leafy living organisms masquerading as tree facts. Keep reading to learn the five tree myths we’re debunking so you can better understand trees and find out how to care for them properly when you plant them this Arbor Day.

Garden with trees
Mint Images / Getty Images

Myth 1: Trees can “heal” themselves

Trees can’t repair damaged tissue like people and animals because of their rigid cell walls. When our bodies heal wounds, they replace or repair injured tissue. Instead of fixing anything, trees “compartmentalize” wounds. The damaged tissue stays permanent (but localized) as the tree grows wound wood over the impacted area to seal it away.

Recommended Videos

Keeping this in mind, don’t throw caution to the wind and inadvertently harm your trees with your garden and lawn equipment (such as your lawnmower). If your tree gets injured, allow it to seal off the wound on its own; refrain from applying any coats or preservatives to the injury, which could worsen matters.

Myth 2: Tree roots crack sidewalks

Tree roots emerging from sidewalks are usually a result of poor planning rather than an aggressively growing tree. Cement actually cracks on its own as soil volume changes from moisture level and temperature. When cement cracks, roots want to move toward the opening to access more light and air. This movement widens cracks and pushes cement upward.

The real issue at hand is that sidewalks and pathways are designed without consideration for soil conditions. Tree roots may weaken already-cracked cement, but they aren’t responsible for the cracking itself. As you plant trees near cement (if you must), it does help to pick small, slow-growing trees. This way, you can prevent future chances of heaving.  

Person planting a tree
azem / Shutterstock

Myth 3: Extra mulch is beneficial for your tree

Mulch can help plants retain moisture and stay cool in hot weather. That said, too much mulch can pose problems for your tree, particularly when it comes to soil aeration and moisture levels. Roots growing up to the mulch can lead to root girdling when roots circle around the trunk at or below the soil line and eventually kill the tree.

And then, of course, mulch can conceal rot and decay on the tree base. When in doubt, go with 3 or 4 inches of mulch. If you have your tree in compact, poor-draining soil, you may want to go with even less mulch to prevent any chance of root rot.

Myth 4: Staking trees actually makes them stronger

Although beneficial in some cases, staking down a tree isn’t always necessary; it can actually contribute to root girdling if done improperly. On the whole, trees can support themselves just fine. Contrary to popular belief, they can benefit from some movement, which allows them to develop strong taper and balance.

Of course, younger trees and trees in windy areas can use some staking to stay grounded, but staking these trees may not significantly help their roots and trunks grow stronger. Even in these cases, you eventually want to remove your stakes about six months to a year after placing them down.  

Person planting a tree
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Myth 5: You should plant your tree deeply to help it develop roots

There’s a misconception that trees establish stronger roots if you plant them deeply. If you have well-draining soil, you should never plant your tree deeper than the height of its root ball. So what should your tree look like? After planting, your root flare should be visible. Even a mere half-inch above the root ball can lead to improper water uptake and a weaker tree.

Deep planting can cause the trunk to break down at the soil line, which may kill the tree over time. Your planting hole should be wider than it is deep, as tree roots typically spread horizontally more than they do so vertically to stabilize the trunk.

The next time you bring a tree home for your garden, keep these tree facts in mind for the healthiest and most vigorous growth possible. Even after Arbor Day, you can still celebrate all the wonders of trees by planting your own. Remember to plant your tree deep enough (but not too deep) and go easy on the staking and mulching. With due diligence, you’ll be able to enjoy the rewards of your careful maintenance for years down the line. 

Topics
Stacey Nguyen
Stacey's work has appeared on sites such as POPSUGAR, HelloGiggles, Buzzfeed, The Balance, TripSavvy, and more. When she's…
Want a stunning willow tree? Find the right type for your zone
Choose one of these willow trees to beautify your yard
A weeping willow tree planted in a patch of grass surrounded by stone in front of a building

Willow trees are perhaps best known for their striking silhouette, with long, hanging branches dangling over water. While not all types of willows have this iconic shape, they are still gorgeous and easy to care for. If you want to add a few willow trees to your yard or garden, here are some of our favorites! These 5 types of willow trees cover a range of sizes and climates, so you’ll have options no matter what type of environment you want to plant your willow tree in.
Weeping willow

Weeping willows are perhaps one of the most easily recognizable trees, and they’re a great fit for many yards and gardens. While they most often grow beside lakes or rivers, you don’t need a water feature to grow a weeping willow. As long as the soil is regularly moist, your weeping willow will do just fine.

Read more
The best time to prune dogwood trees: Everything you need to know about dogwood care
How to grow a lush and thriving dogwood tree
Dogwood tree with pink flowers

Dogwood trees are a great choice for almost any garden or yard. They’re medium-sized with lovely flowers in white or pink and grow bright red berries that birds love to eat. If you’ve decided to add a dogwood tree to your life, but aren’t sure how to care for it, then you’re in luck! In this helpful guide, we’ll tell you everything you need to know to make sure your new tree thrives, from how to plant your sapling to when the best time to prune dogwood trees is.
Planting

After choosing your dogwood tree, the first thing you’ll want to do is put it in the ground. Before that, however, you have to choose a planting site. Dogwoods, being shorter trees, are understory trees. This means that, in the wild, they’re shaded and protected by taller trees. Keep this in mind when choosing where to plant your dogwood, and select somewhere with morning sun and afternoon shade. In milder climates, you can plant them in full sun, but remember they’ll need to be watered more frequently.

Read more
A guide to growing a thriving olive tree
Everything you need to know about choosing and growing this popular tree
A grove of olive trees

Olive trees have a long history of cultivation—from ancient Greece, where olive groves were tended with care, to the modern orchards that supply your kitchens with olive oil and tapenades. If you’re looking for the freshest olive tapenade, you might consider growing an olive tree yourself. In that case, you’ll want to know all the tips and tricks for keeping your olive tree alive and thriving. Here’s everything you need to know about taking your olive tree from seedling to success.
What type of olive tree should you grow?

There are many types of olive trees, and each one has its merits. Which one you choose is ultimately based on what you’d like to use the olives for. If you want an olive tree but no olives, try a fruitless olive tree variety like Majestic Beauty or Swan Hill.

Read more