Skip to main content

What not to compost and why

adding scraps to a compost bin
Image used with permission by copyright holder

What happens in a healthy composting system is nothing short of astonishing. An entire ecosystem of creatures, including fungi, bacteria, actinomycetes, and a variety of macroinvertebrates, transform home, yard, and garden waste into an extremely valuable soil amendment. Making compost is an excellent way to divert trash away from the landfill and produce something that will improve your yard and garden.

Several factors determine composting efficiency such as particle size, the ratio of carbon to nitrogen in the mix, oxygen and water levels, system volume, and more. While it’s possible to compost virtually any organic material in a high-efficiency system, certain items should be avoided in the interests of health and safety.

Inorganic and non-biodegradable materials

Composting only works on biodegradable, organic materials, such as produce scraps, coffee grounds, shredded paper, fallen leaves, and sawdust. Garbage items like plastic, glass, aluminium foil, and metal don’t break down and turn the pile into a useless trash heap. Before adding anything to a compost pile, be sure to remove wrappers and packaging materials.

Coated or glossy paper

It can be helpful to add shredded newsprint, cardboard, paper towels, and other non-glossy paper products to the compost. They add high levels of much needed carbon to the mix, which becomes the fuel for decomposer microbes. However, the inks and surface coatings of magazines, cereal boxes, and other glossy or coated paper items may contain toxic substances that could damage plants when applied as compost. Recycle glossy paper instead.

Animal-based food scraps

If a stray chicken bone or a scrap of cheese accidentally finds its way into the bin, no problem. Just bury it. But avoid adding animal-based food scraps on a regular, intentional basis. Although meat, bones, and dairy products are biodegradable, these items attract rodents, raccoons, and other unwanted pests to the compost bin. Better to place them in the trash.

hands beside a seedling
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Preserved wood scraps and sawdust

In general, sawdust, small lumber scraps, wood chips, and bark add high levels of beneficial carbon to the compost pile. Tree trimmings and lumber waste help develop a desirable crumbly texture in the compost. But treated lumber contains toxic chemicals that don’t break down within the composting environment and carry over to the detriment of garden projects. Avoid composting pressure-treated lumber, as well as painted or stained lumber.

Cooking oil or oily foods

Cooking oil and oily foods slow down the decomposition process. Although they’re biodegradable, the oil content infiltrates the pile to inhibit the proper movement of water and air to the microbes. Until the oils degrade, they slow down the whole process. At the same time, animals are attracted to the scents of fats, oils, and grease. Rather than upsetting the balance, dispose of these items elsewhere.

Pet waste

Dog and cat waste transmit harmful microbes such as E. coli, salmonella, ringworm, tapeworm, and others. Under ideal conditions, these pathogens could be broken down within the composting system, but the process requires regular handling which exposes the gardener to a higher risk of infection. Plus, it really stinks. It’s best to avoid the risk and leave pet waste out of the compost system.

Weeds and diseased plants

When you remove weeds and diseased plants from the garden, you may be tempted to compost them. In a hot compost pile, disease spores, weed seeds, and perennial roots are killed off. But if the pile doesn’t gain enough heat, or stays hot long enough, the weed and disease problems will be further spread when you apply the compost. For those with experience maintaining a hot compost pile, these issues may be of no concern. For the rest of us, it’s best to leave these items out.

Plants that have been treated with herbicide or pesticide

The environment in a compost pile is surprisingly hostile to many of the herbicides and pesticides used to control weeds and insects in the garden and landscape. Fungi, bacteria, and heat, have an amazing ability to break down some complex chemicals. Unfortunately some compounds resist degradation and the secondary products from “decayed” chemicals can be harmful as well. Rather than taking a chance on making toxic compost, leave out any chemically-treated plants.

Editors' Recommendations

Mark Wolfe
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Mark Wolfe is a freelance writer who specializes in garden, landscaping, and home improvement. After two decades in the…
Your guide to growing garlic in winter for a delicious season-long harvest
Grow garlic in winter with these tips
Garlic bulbs and cloves

Garlic is a great addition to any dish, making it a popular plant to grow. It doesn't take up much room, is resistant to many pests and diseases, and is easy to care for, making it a great plant for beginners as well. If you're a fan of garlic and want to extend your harvest, then you might be interested in learning how to grow garlic in winter. Growing vegetables in winter can be tricky due to the weather, but luckily, garlic is easy to grow in any season! This handy guide will explain everything you need to know about how to grow garlic in winter.

When should you start your winter garlic?
Garlic needs several weeks of temperatures that are at or below 40 degrees Fahrenheit to develop properly. However, they also need enough time to grow roots before the ground freezes. Plant your garlic a little before the first frosts of the year, but avoid planting them right before a big freeze. Garlic doesn’t do well in heat, so plant your garlic once the weather has begun to cool.

Read more
8 beautiful, fall-blooming perennials to add to your garden
From aster to sneezeweed, here are the best autumn flowers to grow
Scarecrow among fall flowers

A beautiful year-round landscape is the result of planning for diversity. After all, plants come in a huge range of forms and types, from the tallest trees to the tiniest flowers. The appeal of each kind changes throughout the seasons, with some showing off early in the year and others displaying peak interest much later. Plenty of attention goes to the bright foliage of deciduous trees in autumn, but let’s not overlook the fall-blooming perennials.

Perennials are the herbaceous (non-woody) plants that grow back year after year. Although they typically offer a much shorter blooming season compared with annual flowers, perennials offer a variety of other benefits. These late bloomers look their best as the summer annuals begin to look ragged and worn. By blooming within a window of only a few short weeks, they add to the evolving seasonal interest of the landscape. Plus, many attract and support native wildlife, like butterflies, birds, and bees, by producing the nectar, pollen, and seeds they need for nourishment.

Read more
Follow this lemon tree winter guide to make sure that your lemon tree doesn’t suffer when the cold hits
Everything you need to know about keeping your lemon tree alive this winter

If you're one of the many people who own a lemon tree, you know just how sturdy those trees can be. But the truth is, harsh winters can still threaten your plant. While your lemon trees can survive a few chilly nights with the proper frost and cold protection, too many freezing nights will decrease their likelihood of survival.

Depending on which climate zone you live in, you may be able to choose whether to keep your tree outdoors during the winter holidays. If your winters are cold and brisk at night, err on the safe side and bring the tree indoors. If you live in a warmer climate, you can opt to keep your tree outside with some precautions.

Read more