Skip to main content

‘Should I Compost in the Fall?’ Yes, Absolutely! Here’s What to Use and How to Do It

Help the environment and your plants by composting this fall

Fall is the perfect time to begin composting. It’s the end of the growing season and there’s plenty of yard debris to clean up, which means plenty of startup ingredients. Plus, the cool, dry weather is perfect for working outdoors. More importantly, year-round plants like trees, shrubs, and perennials benefit from a fresh application of compost heading into the dormant season.

When you ask the question, "Should I compost in the fall?" — here's your answer: Yes, because you can save money, salvage valuable plant nutrients, and divert yard debris from landfills by making your own compost. If you're intimidated, don't be! It's a simple process that only requires minimal intervention on your part; You just add the ingredients and let nature do most of the work for you. Here's how.

Difficulty

Easy

What You Need

  • Lawnmower with a bagger attachment

  • Water

  • Tarp

  • Enclosed bin (if desired)

  • Compost tumbling bin (if desired)

  • Woodchipper or shredder

  • Brown compost ingredients (dried leaves and grass, straw, corn stalks, etc.)

  • Green compost ingredients (fresh grass clippings, green leaves, vegetable scraps, etc.)

  • Manure fork

If you’ve ever spent time raking or blowing autumn leaves before bagging them for the trash company to haul away, you’ll be glad to know there's a better (and easier!) way. Fallen leaves, along with most other landscape debris, can be composted. This includes, but is not limited to:

  • Grass clippings
  • Annual flowers that have finished blooming
  • Vegetable plants after the harvest
  • Weeds
  • Pruned or fallen sticks, twigs, and branches
  • Natural autumn decorations like pumpkins, straw bales, and corn stalks

You can compost virtually any organic waste under ideal conditions, including traditional “taboo” items like citrus fruit, onion peels, and diseased leaves. Just be sure to monitor the green-to-brown ingredient ratio, moisture content, and aeration.

A person mowing the lawn with a black push mower
NinaMalyna/Shutterstock

Start with an easy mix

If you can mow the lawn, you can make compost.

Step 1: When the leaves begin to fall, use a lawnmower with a bagger attachment to collect them. This way, the leaves will be shredded and mixed with grass clippings, which will help both break down more efficiently.

Step 2: Pile the mixture in an out-of-the-way location where it can decompose on its own.

Step 3: Alternatively, water the pile, cover it with a tarp, and turn it once a week for faster processing.

pPle of fall leaves

Fill a bin or build a pile

If you have large quantities of material to compost, batch processing works best. Choose from either an enclosed bin or an open pile. Bins keep the moisture consistent throughout the batch, protect the outside surfaces from microbe-killing sunlight, and keep animals out of the compost.

Tumbling bins make it much easier to keep the batch aerated. Open piles are fast, easy, and free to build, but take longer to process. Covering an open pile with a tarp can address many of the concerns that bins solve.

Wood chipper

Pay attention to ingredient size

Composting occurs thanks to billions of microbes that colonize the surfaces of the compost ingredients. Smaller ingredients have a greater surface area, which means more space for more microbes. So rather than simply piling up pumpkins, tree limbs, and corn stalks, you should chop up bulky items so that the particle size is no larger than 2 inches in any dimension.

Step 1: Chop up bulky items like pumpkins, tree limbs, and corn stalks into 2-inch pieces.

Step 2: Use a lawnmower with a bagger to capture high-nitrogen grass clippings. It’s also great for shredding fallen leaves, annual flowers, vegetable plants, and small twigs. You’ll need to sharpen the blade afterward.

Step 3: Use a woodchipper or shredder to grind tree branches up to 3 inches thick, as well as corn stalks, coarse weeds, and woody vines.

Two large canvas bags of compost and grass clippings

Build a favorable mix of compost ingredients

In composting, all of the ingredients are categorized into carbon-rich “browns” and the nitrogen-rich “greens.” Browns include things like dried leaves, straw, corn stalks, dried grasses, and shredded paper or cardboard. Greens would be fresh grass clippings, green leaves, green weeds and garden plants, kitchen veggie scraps, and coffee grounds.

The microbes that do the work of composting use carbon as fuel and nitrogen for growth and reproduction. For the best results (fast decomposition, high quality compost) they need a consistent supply of about 70% carbon and 30% nitrogen. Items in the brown category and the green category include both carbon and nitrogen but at different levels.

Step 1: To achieve something close to the ideal carbon-to-nitrogen ratio, start the pile with about three parts brown material to one part green.

Step 2: Adjust the ratio as needed by adding more brown or green ingredients.

A person holding compost in their hands

Maintaining and using fall compost

To get usable compost quickly, a bit of maintenance is necessary.

Step 1: Shred and pile the ingredients in the 3:1 brown-to-green ratio, wetting it as you go. The moisture consistency should be similar to a sponge that has been soaked and gently wrung out.

Step 2: Cover the pile or close the bin and leave it alone for about 14 days.

Step 3: After the first two weeks, turn and mix the pile. With a tumbler, simply rotate the chamber a few times. Otherwise, use a manure fork to manually turn and mix the pile, like tossing a salad. The interior should have warmed to some extent by this point, and it may even radiate a significant amount of heat.

Step 4: If the compost seems dry, add water. If it smells bad, add more brown material. If it’s not getting hot, add more green material.

Step 5: After turning the pile, cover it up again.

Step 6: Repeat the above steps weekly.

Step 7: The compost is ready to use after 6 to 10 weeks. You can apply it immediately by spreading a 1-inch layer across the root zones of landscape plants, or you can store it for later use.

Making compost with landscape waste in the fall is an excellent way to close the nutrient loop and reduce pollution. Your yard and garden will thank you for it.

Editors' Recommendations

Mark Wolfe
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Mark Wolfe is a freelance writer who specializes in garden, landscaping, and home improvement. After two decades in the…
What should you actually do if you find a baby bird on the ground in your garden?
What to do when a baby bird falls out of the nest
Several older bird chicks in a nest

As nesting season approaches, you, like many other gardeners, might be trying to attract birds to your garden. Birds are beautiful and useful to have around, as they eat many common garden pests.

If you’re successful, and birds nest in your yard, then there’s a chance you’ll find a baby bird that fell out of its nest. There are some popular myths about what you should and shouldn’t do in that case, but here are the facts.

Read more
Don’t wait until fall to plant an autumn blaze maple! Here’s how to plant your own today
Growing an autumn blaze maple tree
A large maple tree with red leaves

If you’re in the market for a lovely new tree, then the autumn blaze maple might be just what you’re looking for. Maple trees are easy to care for and can provide you with delicious maple syrup, but autumn blaze maples in particular are a delight. To find out what makes these maple trees special and how to grow your own, just keep reading!

Read more
Want to avoid itchy rashes this spring? Here’s how to get rid of poison ivy from you garden or yard
Steps on how to rid of poison ivy safely
Poison ivy sprouts surrounded by fallen leaves

When you’re out in your yard or garden, there’s always a risk of encountering an irritating plant. Whether the irritation is emotional, as with stubborn weeds, or physical, like accidentally grabbing a thorny vine, it isn’t fun. One particularly irritating plant is poison ivy, which is both stubborn and can irritate your skin. If you need to know how to get rid of poison ivy, this is the guide for you.

Read more