Skip to main content

Composting: Gardening game changer or stinky myth?

Plant enthusiasts of all kinds, both organic purists and non-organic gardeners alike, are passionate about great compost. They call it “black gold,” because they say it makes flowers bloom better, vegetables produce more, and grass grow greener. If you’ve tried composting and had unfavorable results, such as foul odors, or if you just think the whole process seems a bit too messy and likely to attract pests, you may wonder if it’s really worthwhile. With the rise in municipal and private enterprise composting services that process your waste for you, there are incentives to leave it to the experts. They haul it away, turn it into good soil, and you may or may not ever see it again. But for gardeners, there are even greater benefits to be had from doing it yourself. 

Metal gardening tools, gardening gloves, and several colorful flowers arranged on a patch of soil
Image used with permission by copyright holder

What are the benefits of composting?

The benefits of composting are plentiful and makes it worth the effort. For one, composting diverts food waste and other plant debris out of landfills and reduces methane emissions, which are some of the most harmful greenhouse gasses. Making compost at home is a great way to recycle nutrients within your landscape and lower the need for a significant portion of lawn and garden fertilizers. When you compost instead of throwing away vegetable scraps, fallen leaves, weeds, and grass clippings, you harvest the carbon, nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium, and micronutrients that make up the physical mass of these items. Nutrients in homemade compost can replace up to one-third of the fertilizer that you previously applied to your garden.

Gardening with compost improves soil structure, boosts soil biodiversity, and builds a more resilient garden. Unlike conventional fertilizers, compost increases soil organic matter. It improves the soil’s ability to balance water retention and drainage. The bacteria and fungi that perform the action of composting can suppress plant diseases and other garden pests.

Does compost affect plant growth?

Compost improves soil structure and provides consistent nutrient availability for stronger root development and better overall plant growth. Plants that grow in soils with compost have fewer problems with disease and insect infestations. These soils require less frequent watering and are more likely to stay within the ideal pH range for optimum plant growth.

Compost helps plants use fertilizer more efficiently and provides consistent nutrient availability over time. In order for organic fertilizer to work, microbes such as those in compost must first consume and break it down into plant-available nutrients. In the case of conventional synthetic fertilizers, compost acts as a soil buffer to improve its effectiveness and reduce the likelihood of pollution. Synthetic fertilizers are designed to be used right away. Whatever is not absorbed runs off, and can pollute adjacent water sources. Gardens where compost is used in combination with synthetic fertilizers have little or no runoff because the microbes consume  excess nutrients, and then release them for plants to use later. 

adding scraps to a compost bin
Anna Hoychuk / Shutterstock

Does compost stink?

Compost does not stink if conditions are favorable. The carbon to nitrogen (C:N) ratio is a critical factor in keeping the smell away as is proper aeration. The primary composting microbes are oxygen-loving (aerobic) bacteria. They use carbon as a source of energy and nitrogen allows them to synthesize proteins. A healthy C:N ratio for them is about 30:1. Like other living things, they also need an adequate supply of water. So, if your compost is moist, well aerated, and has a C:N ratio between 25:1 and 40:1, you won’t have a problem.

Bad smells are indications that the process is not happening the way it should. If the compost gives off an odor of ammonia, that means there is an excessive amount of nitrogen in the mix. Eliminate the odor by mixing in high carbon materials like wood chips, shredded paper, or shredded cardboard. A rotten or sulphur smell means that the mix has become compacted or is too wet and anaerobic bacteria are flourishing. Aerate the pile to get rid of the stink, and if it’s slimy or soggy, add some dry high carbon material. 

woman in a garden holding carrots
wavebreakmedia / Shutterstock

Compost is a game changer

Finished compost is dark brown with a crumbly texture. The smell should be pleasantly earthy. It contains beneficial microbes that help plants use nutrients efficiently and suppress diseases and pests in the soil.  The bulk organic matter in compost is an excellent soil amendment for any garden setting, improving drainage while increasing water holding capacity. Mix it with your native garden soil or with potting soil when planting new plants. Use it as mulch around vegetables and flowers. Spread a thin layer on your lawn. Compost is absolutely worth the effort.

Editors' Recommendations

Mark Wolfe
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Mark Wolfe is a freelance writer who specializes in garden, landscaping, and home improvement. After two decades in the…
5 outdoor gardening projects to focus on this November
Things you can do to improve your garden this November
Stone house with yard full of golden leaves

November is the last month of fall, when many plants have already put out their final harvest and others are going dormant for winter. Your garden is slowing down, and there are fewer things to do outdoors. If you're the type of person who loves being active and productive, or if you have kids that need to be kept busy, then this might be a frustrating time for you. Don't worry, though. There are still a few things that you can and should do outdoors in November to improve your garden. Add these five November gardening tasks to your checklist to help your garden thrive through winter.

Harvest the last of your fall garden
If you had a fall vegetable garden, be sure to bring in the last of the harvest. You may have already completed this step if you live in a cooler region, but, for those further south, this is the perfect time to wrap up your harvests. Be sure to store them somewhere dark and cool, like the fridge or a cellar (depending on what you were growing), or can them so they last longer. Any produce that’s left on the vine for too much longer will begin to rot or suffer frost damage.

Read more
6 gorgeous mums to add color to your autumn garden 
How to find the perfect mum for your fall garden and properly care for it
A chrysanthemum plant with several round, reddish-pink flowers

Come early fall, you’ll find beautiful mums in virtually every color lining nursery display tables. The garden mum, or chrysanthemum, is a universally beloved autumn flower, and luckily, it’s easy to find. Of course, there are so many different blooms to choose from, many coming in whimsical, Dr. Seuss-esque shapes.

With so many options, it can be overwhelming to find just the right one for cozying up your garden — even if you're only keeping it for the fall season. If you’re wondering which mum best suits your landscape, keep reading to learn about the different types of autumn garden mums.

Read more
8 beautiful, fall-blooming perennials to add to your garden
From aster to sneezeweed, here are the best autumn flowers to grow
Scarecrow among fall flowers

A beautiful year-round landscape is the result of planning for diversity. After all, plants come in a huge range of forms and types, from the tallest trees to the tiniest flowers. The appeal of each kind changes throughout the seasons, with some showing off early in the year and others displaying peak interest much later. Plenty of attention goes to the bright foliage of deciduous trees in autumn, but let’s not overlook the fall-blooming perennials.

Perennials are the herbaceous (non-woody) plants that grow back year after year. Although they typically offer a much shorter blooming season compared with annual flowers, perennials offer a variety of other benefits. These late bloomers look their best as the summer annuals begin to look ragged and worn. By blooming within a window of only a few short weeks, they add to the evolving seasonal interest of the landscape. Plus, many attract and support native wildlife, like butterflies, birds, and bees, by producing the nectar, pollen, and seeds they need for nourishment.

Read more